Using the Output Embedding to Improve Language Models
This 2017 paper explores the role and importance of the output embedding matrix (V) in neural network language models (NLMs) and compares it to the input embedding matrix (U).
The authors make several key findings and recommendations:
Output embedding quality
In the word2vec skip-gram model, the output embedding is only slightly inferior to the input embedding in terms of quality metrics. However, in recurrent neural network-based language models, the output embedding outperforms the input embedding.
Weight tying
The authors recommend tying the input and output embeddings (i.e., setting U = V) in NLMs.
They show that the tied embedding evolves more similarly to the output embedding than to the input embedding of the untied model. Tying the embeddings leads to improved perplexity in various language models, both with and without dropout regularization.
Regularization
When not using dropout, the authors propose adding an additional projection matrix P before V and applying regularization to P.
Neural machine translation
Weight tying can significantly reduce the size of neural translation models (by more than half) without compromising performance.
The paper also provides a brief overview of related work in NNLMs, word embeddings, and neural machine translation.
Summary
In summary, this paper challenges the common practice of focusing solely on the input embedding matrix in NLMs and demonstrates the benefits of using the output embedding matrix through weight tying and regularization techniques.
The findings suggest that the output embedding matrix is a valuable component in NNLMs and can be leveraged to improve model performance and efficiency.
Practical Applications
The practical applications of the techniques and findings presented in this paper are primarily in the development of more efficient and effective language modelling and machine translation systems.
Language Modelling
Neural Network Language Models (NNLMs) are widely used for tasks such as speech recognition, text generation, and predictive typing.
The paper shows that by tying the input and output embeddings in NLMs, the model size can be reduced, and the perplexity of the model can be improved.
This means that weight-tied NLMs can be more efficient in terms of memory and computational requirements while delivering better language modelling performance. This is particularly useful for deploying language models on resource-constrained devices like smartphones or embedded systems.
Machine Translation
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) models have become the state-of-the-art approach for automating translation between languages.
The paper demonstrates that by applying weight tying in NMT models, particularly the three-way weight tying (TWWT) technique, the model size can be significantly reduced (up to 52%) without compromising translation quality.
This is crucial for deploying NMT models in real-world scenarios where memory and computational resources may be limited, such as on-device translation on smartphones or real-time translation services on the web.
Model Compression
Weight tying can be seen as a form of model compression, where the number of parameters in the model is reduced without significantly impacting performance.
This is important for deploying deep learning models in production environments where memory and computational constraints are a concern. The techniques presented in the paper can be applied to other similar architectures to achieve model compression.
Transfer Learning
The paper's findings on the similarity between the learned embeddings in weight-tied and untied models can potentially be useful for transfer learning scenarios.
The insights gained from analysing the embeddings can guide researchers in developing more effective techniques for transferring knowledge from pre-trained models to downstream tasks.
In summary, the practical applications of the paper's findings are in developing more efficient and effective language modelling and machine translation systems that can be deployed in real-world scenarios with resource constraints.
The techniques presented can also be applied to other similar architectures for model compression and potentially aid in transfer learning research.
Last updated
